I have, over the past few years, developed something of an unhealthy fixation with disappointing regional British hotels. You see, being in my early thirties, I have spent much of the last few summers touring the country to whichever picturesque but often extremely rural location the latest couple in the line-up has chosen for their nuptials. And, while the weddings themselves have always been glorious affairs, the hotels they necessitate (and the sums of cash I have been forced to pay for them) have been decidedly less so.

There was the ‘historic’ Cambridge hotel where I can only assume the descriptor was referring to the ancient mismatched furniture and restaurant which hadn’t been touched since the mid-’50s. (They may be on to something there; it’s now so old-fashioned it’s almost cool again.) Then there was the storied Sussex coaching inn resting on the laurels of proximity to a Harry Potter filming location in order to part unsuspecting American tourists upwards of £200 per night with a two-night minimum stay. Again, the breakfast room hinted that this may once have been a rather lovely, even grand, hostelry. Now it feels more like staying above your old man’s favourite boozer.

Now, I know hospitality is a seriously tough business. Rising energy costs, staff shortages, and the return of international travel post-Covid have all made the domestic travel market a tricky game, but herein lies the paradox. Right now, BA Holidays is offering a week in Spain, Greece or Turkey in August – where the sunshine is guaranteed and the hotels come with pools and multiple dining options – for around £450 per person. Why would any Brit with an ounce of common sense pay the same to spend a long weekend in a past-its-prime hotel where the most exciting local attraction may well be a model village?

It needn’t be this way. Step in The Alfriston, a recently re-opened Sussex hotel where rooms start at £150 a night – a full £50 less than I paid for the aforementioned neighbouring Sussex hotel with an inexplicably recently installed avocado bath suite. At The Alfriston, all things avocado are limited to breakfast. Where they belong.

The Alfriston could easily have been consigned to the same fate as its neighbour. Before reopening in March 2025, it was known as the Deans Place Hotel, occupying the eponymous 400-year-old manor house which, after spending centuries being traded around various local nobles, landowners and wealthy citizens, was converted into a hotel in the late 1930s. A quick trip in the Wayback Machine unearths a website proudly proclaiming its four-star status, ‘traditional’ interiors, 55” televisions and refurbished bathrooms. You get the idea.

In 2023, the hotel was bought by the Signet Collection, the hotel group behind the highly regarded Mitre near Hampton Court and The Barnsdale in Rutland. Two years, and one seriously extensive refurbishment later, it reopened having become as close to a luxury resort as you’re likely to find in the UK.

Perhaps in an effort to shed any existing preconceptions, the hotel is now named for the nearby village of Alfriston: a charming hamlet which, in true British fashion, has no post office, butcher or corner shop but is home to (at least) four pubs servicing its 829 residents (one of which is owned by Rocco Forte Hotels scion, Alex Polizzi). And, while from the outside, The Alfriston appears to be all Grade II-listed tradition and classic English country hotel grandeur, inside it’s a rather different story.

Signet enlisted local interior designer and colour consultant Georgie Wykeham to oversee the design, and you’ll see much of her own furniture range, named The Colourist, on display. Given I’ve mentioned the word twice in the last sentence, normally a big journalistic no-no, it will probably come as no surprise that colour is very much The Alfriston’s thing.

The vibe is eccentric English country house but, instead of your granny’s Persian rugs and heavy antique furniture, Wykeham has opted for a soft palette of sky blues, golden yellows, deep plums and burnt oranges. In our Heritage room, scalloped accents on bedside tables and mirrors lend everything an organic feel, while prints by Tilly Lock add playfulness, picture windows allow for streams of natural light, and the bathtub is strategically placed to take in gorgeous views of the Cuckmere Valley beyond.

Downstairs, the 1554 Brasserie is painted such a perfect shade of muted pink that I can’t resist asking for the exact shade for my own living room. Should poring over Farrow & Ball catalogues not be your thing, however, there are plenty of other reasons to book a table.

We’re visiting on a Monday night and I’m surprised to find the dining room almost completely full by the time we arrive for our 7.30pm reservation. The hotel has, I’m told, become the destination of choice for well-heeled travellers heading to the nearby Glyndebourne Festival (Le Nozze di Figaro is on the schedule for the following day), while 1554 has established itself as a place for destination dining in its own right.

Food here is refined but comforting and you get the sense the kitchen is content to settle for happy customers rather than chasing starry accolades. A generous starter of picked crabmeat sparks a debate with a neighbouring French diner about the necessity of the crumpet underneath. We dispel no stereotypes when he argues for a classically Gallic lighter touch, while I take up the mantle for carbohydrates. We both, however, agree the crab is top notch.

My husband is served a first class rib-eye steak with exemplary fries, while I, if I’m being picky, would argue my chicken Milanese could have done with a touch more seasoning and something a little more acidic and spritely on the side than the accompanying marinated tomato sauce. The wine list, meanwhile, is vast but carefully considered and offers plenty of options from the surrounding Sussex vineyards; the Rathfinny Estate is within stomping distance and well worth a visit while you’re in the area.

That, however, would be contingent on you being able to tear yourself away from the grounds of the hotel itself. As I said, The Alfriston is more resort than hotel, so there’s plenty to keep you occupied. Set in acres of its own landscaped gardens, and highly welcoming of furry friends, grab a pair of wellies from the communal welly wall and head out to discover the South Downs Way (should you not be distracted by the plethora of garden games dotting the grounds before you get there).

Alternatively, simply grab a bathrobe and head to the spa. Open to hotel guests, as well as for external spa days, a concise range of signature Signet treatments, as well as facials and massages by vegan skincare brand Gaia, are on offer. There’s also a sauna, steam room and relaxation lounge. But what really gives The Alfriston a resort vibe is its blissful heated outdoor pool. Fringed with cushioned sun beds, even on the drizzly morning we braved a dip it was plenty warm enough to swim; on a sunny afternoon it must be glorious.

So, has The Alfriston changed my dim view of rural British hotels? While I fear it may currently be the exception that proves the rule, it’s certainly a good start.

Rooms from £150 per night, visit thealfriston.com

Read more: The best five-star hotels in London