As art continues to evolve into an asset class rivalling property and private equity, the way it is bought and managed is changing too. A series of high-profile fraud cases has exposed the vulnerabilities that can sit beneath even the most prestigious transactions.

The downfall of Inigo Philbrick, who was sentenced to seven years in prison for selling overlapping shares in artworks and defrauding investors of more than $86 million, brought rare public scrutiny to the mechanics of private art deals. Elsewhere, the long-running scandal at the Knoedler Gallery saw more than 60 forged works sold over 15 years, with losses estimated at around $80 million, while a Canadian fraud ring linked to Norval Morrisseau produced over 1,000 fake paintings, with profits believed to exceed $100 million.

Against this backdrop, a new breed of specialist art lawyer is emerging, bringing structure and scrutiny to an increasingly complex market. Once considered a niche advisory role, legal specialists in art and luxury are now quietly embedded across the lifecycle of fine art collecting.

From advising on acquisition to transport, lending, storage and succession, their involvement reflects a broader shift in how ultra-high-net-worths are approaching risk.

When legal advice becomes essential

For many collectors, it is a matter of timing. Legal advice tends to become essential as transactions grow more complex, rather than simply more valuable.

“An experienced art lawyer can tailor their advice to fit most situations and budgets, and provide their clients with reassurance and guidance to save them from costly mistakes at any stage of the collecting journey,” says Petra Warrington, partner in the Art & Luxury team at Wedlake Bell.

High-value purchases may attract attention, but it’s the structure of a transaction that often determines whether legal oversight is required. “The need for legal advice is often based on the complexity of the transaction and the negotiating positions of the parties, rather than value per se,” Warrington explains.

At the more straightforward end of the market, deals can still be handled with relative ease. “Many transactions at all levels of the market are completed on the basis of a simple invoice and that may be acceptable when buying directly from reputable galleries,” she says, noting that consumer protection laws still apply to private individuals purchasing art.

However, the landscape changes quickly once collectors move beyond gallery purchases. “Where collectors are drawn into private sales with potentially complicated transaction structures involving multiple parties, or are unsure of who they are transacting with or how to verify the information presented to them, an art lawyer will help to de-risk and potentially reduce the total transaction cost.”

The cost of getting it wrong

Art collecting is often driven by instinct. The emotional pull of a work can be immediate and compelling, and in many cases, decisions are made quickly. Yet that same instinct can sometimes lead to costly oversights.

“Art is, of course, a passion for many people and so naturally purchases are made with heart rather than head,” Warrington says. “Equally other people see art as an investment but it can be difficult to predict potential returns during a falling market, as we have seen recently.”

In practice, the most significant risks are based around provenance, condition and the reliability of counterparties. “The key is doing business with reputable counterparties and, if in doubt as to the more specialist aspects such as condition or authenticity, seeking the right advice,” she adds.

For UHNW collectors, these risks are amplified by scale. After all, a single acquisition can involve multiple intermediaries, cross-border considerations and layers of contractual detail. Without proper due diligence, what might appear to be a straightforward purchase can quickly become rather complicated.

The legal considerations of collecting

The role of the art lawyer doesn’t end at acquisition. In fact, in many cases, that is only the beginning. As collections become more international, the movement of artworks introduces a host of regulatory considerations.

“Legal advice becomes necessary if a collector wishes to transport artworks across borders, store artworks in different jurisdictions, or lend their collection, as there are a number of cross-border issues, such as compliance with import and export laws, that need to be addressed,” Warrington says.

The implications of overlooking these requirements can be significant, “expensive and sometimes damaging,” she adds. For collectors who lend to institutions or store works in multiple jurisdictions, these considerations become part of the ongoing management of the collection. Insurance, indemnity, liability and contractual obligations all require careful attention, often best undertaken by an expert.

With an eye to the long term, as collections evolve, so too do the legal questions surrounding them. “Issues such as tax and structuring and succession planning become more pressing,” Warrington notes. “Life events, including divorce or death, will have a profound impact on the future of a collection and legal advice can help to safeguard a collection and give the owners peace of mind.”

For UHNW families, this is particularly relevant. Ensuring that these arrangements are robust, tax-efficient and aligned with long-term intentions requires careful planning. In this context, the art lawyer becomes part of a wider advisory network, working alongside wealth managers, tax specialists and family offices to ensure continuity.

A shifting market landscape

The renewed prominence of legal advisors also reflects changes within the art market itself. In recent years, private sales have taken on greater importance, particularly at the top end of the market.

“Geopolitical events and economic uncertainties impact the global art market and present challenges for every sector,” Warrington says. “Private, rather than auction, sales are a focus across the market and tend to be heavily negotiated at the higher end.”

These transactions often involve bespoke terms, extended negotiations and a more strategic approach from both buyers and sellers. “Discerning buyers, prepared to take a strong negotiating position, will reap rewards and will rely on legal advice for structuring the transaction and an effective allocation of risk.”

Sellers, too, are adapting to this environment. “Sellers can de-risk transactions to an extent by limiting wide-reaching warranties and declining extended payment terms, but may find that such terms are needed to secure a deal in a buyer-friendly market.”

For UHNW collectors, the stakes of buying fine art extend well beyond the transaction itself. Reputation, legacy and long-term value all hinge on how a collection is built and maintained and the art lawyer, once a peripheral figure, has quietly taken a central seat at the table.

Read more: Why the super-rich are investing in rare whiskies